The Good Phight
Small victories, large defeats.
Total reads
4,409
This week
76
Rank
#41 of 465
Published
1,973 posts
Most read posts
Featured on Sportsblogs
Run this blog? Add the badge to your site to show readers you're featured — it links back to this page.
Latest Entries
What veteran for veteran trade would you make?
The Good Phight ponders a veteran‑for‑veteran swap after the Phillies‑Braves Wild Card game on September 30, 2026. With MLB trade chatter focusing on players like Logan Gilbert, Steven Kwan and Sandy Alcántara, sources suggest pending free agents could be exchanged to balance risk. The article highlights Philadelphia’s arbitration‑eligible talent such as Brandon Marsh and Orion Kerkering, and asks readers which veteran trade they’d propose.
How to play in-5 Trivia on the SB Nation app
The Good Phight introduces the daily in‑5 trivia game to the SB Nation app, challenging fans to name a player in five clues or fewer. Readers learn the simple rules—guess the player as quickly as possible, post their score in the comments, and compete with others. The game covers MLB, NBA, NFL, MMA, and pro wrestling, with 25 team‑specific options, including a Phillies‑focused version and Eagles trivia. Fans can join the “MLB” community on the app to start playing.
Phillies news: Dave Dombrowski, Kyle Schwarber, Ty France
What’s crazy about this Eagles team is that it’s like watching the Phillies on offense. So many things are going wrong at the same time, yet the same solutions are being tried like they’ll suddenly work. It reminds me of the Phillies’ offense in the playoffs. On to the links. Phillies news: MLB news:
The Phillies and one-year contracts
The Good Phight examines the Phillies’ habit of loading up on one‑year deals since Dave Dombrowski became president, highlighting contracts like Craig Kimbrel, Corey Knebel, Max Kepler, Adolis García and Jordan Romano—each worth $10 million. While some, such as Kimbrel, delivered brief success, most fell short of expectations, especially relievers. Looking ahead to 2027, the team faces outfield gaps and eyeing free agents Seiya Suzuki and Randy Arozarena, yet budget constraints and a pending lockout may limit offers. The author argues the Phillies will likely continue to rely on short‑term contracts and hope to unearth value from the minors.
Will the Phillies finally be successful in the Japanese market?
The Philadelphia Phillies are renewing their push into Japan’s free‑agent market, after previous misses with Yoshinobu Yamamoto and Roki Sasaki. This offseason, they’re reportedly targeting outfielder Teruaki Sato and teenage pitcher Shoki Oda, while also eyeing Seiya Suzuki despite his MLB tenure. The article examines whether 2026 could finally see a Japanese star sign with Philly and what impact that would have on future Pacific talent pipelines.
Phillies news: Jeremy Pena, rotation, Pete Crow-Armstrong
The Good Phight breaks down the Phillies’ outlook for 2027, highlighting a rotation that could be a major asset—or a liability—depending on health and performance. The piece spotlights Jeremy Pena as a potential acquisition despite his rocky 2022 stint, and revisits a Gold Glove discussion, questioning whether Bryson Stott or another player could snag the award. The article also notes MLB updates: Pete Crow‑Armstrong and Cody Bellinger earn Platinum Gloves, the Blue Jays and Cubs lead the league, and off‑field news includes SNY layoffs and Bo Naylor’s testimony in the Emmanuel Clase pitch‑rigging case.
How to improve the Phillies: Starting pitching
The Good Phight breaks down why the Philadelphia Phillies’ starting rotation, despite top‑tier arms like Cristopher Sanchez, Zack Wheeler and Aaron Nola, still lacks depth beyond the top three. The piece highlights Sanchez’s likely third‑place Cy Young finish, Wheeler and Luzardo’s top‑ten chances, and Andrew Painter’s late‑season improvement, but warns that the organization’s minor‑league pipeline offers few reliable seventh‑ or eighth‑starter options. Free‑agent and trade markets are thin, so the article suggests low‑cost moves—bringing back Nestor Cortes, signing Michael Lorenzen to a minor‑league deal, or targeting Trevor Williams—could provide insurance and avoid repeat bullpen‑only games.
Would you trade Jhoan Duran?
The Good Phight debates whether the Phillies should trade closer Jhoan Duran after his late‑season acquisition. While Duran stabilizes the bullpen, his market value is soaring, prompting speculation about swapping him for a top prospect to boost the Phillies' weak farm system. The author argues keeping Duran is crucial for a playoff push, noting Alex McFarlane can’t reliably replace him and the trade cost would outweigh benefits—unless the team flounders by the deadline.
Phillies news: Carlos Mendoza, prospects, Jacob Young
The Good Phight recaps recent MLB headlines, highlighting the Phillies' outlook as Baseball America releases its top ten prospect list and notes manager Carlos Mendoza’s ambitions after coaching the Mets in the 2024 NLDS. The piece also previews upcoming league awards, naming Pete Crow‑Armstrong and Junior Caminero as favorite MVPs, Jacob Misiorowski and Cam Schlittler for Cy Young, and Sal Stewart and Kevin McGonigle for Rookie of the Year. Additional news includes the Nationals rewarding Jacob Young with a four‑year extension, the Cardinals hiring Rob Cerfolio as GM, and the Dodgers parting ways with hitting coach Aaron Bates.
2026 Phillies report card: Brian Keller
Brian Keller finally broke into the majors at age 32 after a tumultuous journey that included stints in the Yankees and Red Sox farms, a brief NPB contract, and a long Tommy John rehab. Signed by Philadelphia on May 18, 2026, he posted a 2.24 ERA in nine AAA starts before debuting on July 25 against the Yankees, delivering three innings and one run. After returning to Lehigh Valley, his performance collapsed, posting a 16‑18 K‑BB ratio and a 41‑run allowance over 30.1 innings, leaving his future uncertain as a free agent. The author grades Keller’s season a C‑.
Where will Alec Bohm be playing in 2027?
The Phillies have declined a qualifying offer for third baseman Alec Bohm, signaling his likely exit in free agency. With a career 101 OPS+ and 107 wRC+ but sub‑par defense, Bohm is expected to land a short‑term deal with a small‑market club needing a corner infielder or DH—potentially the Cleveland Guardians or Kansas City Royals. Although his recent season was among his worst, the absence of a qualifying offer removes draft‑pick penalties, making him a viable, low‑cost option for teams looking to add a league‑average right‑handed bat.
Phillies News: Don Mattingly, Kyle Schwarber, Teruaki Sato
The Good Phight’s latest Phillies roundup blends updates and speculation. Don Mattingly weighs in on the club’s upcoming pitching staff and salary‑cap constraints, while outfielder Kyle Schwarber earns praise as a Silver Slugger finalist. The piece also spotlights Japanese reliever Teruaki Sato’s strong U.S. numbers and teases whether the Braves might move Ronald Acuña Jr. amid fan‑favored trade talk. Readers get a quick pulse on offseason moves and player accolades ahead of the 2027 season.
Left-handed relievers the Phillies could target in free agency
The Phillies enter the 2026 off‑season desperate to fix a left‑handed bullpen that posted the league’s second‑worst 5.12 ERA and a .277 batting average against. After re‑signing Tim Mayza to a one‑year deal, they eye at least one more left‑yielder, with San Diego’s Adrian Morejon—2.83 ERA, 1.9 WAR last season and a career 2.58 ERA—topping the free‑agent list. However, a five‑year, $80 million contract seems unlikely given GM Dave Dombrowski’s habit of short‑term deals and the $11‑12 million arbitration salary slated for closer Jhoan Duran. Veteran Alex Vesia offers a cheaper two‑year, $26 million option, though his walk rate has risen. The article weighs each candidate and the financial constraints shaping Philadelphia’s pen overhaul.
2026 Phillies report cards: J.T. Realmuto
The Good Phight hands J.T. Realmuto a D on his 2026 report card, noting a defensive rebound but a historically weak bat. Realmuto’s challenge success rate sits at an impressive 81%—the highest among starting catchers—yet his wRC+ of 68 ranks near the bottom of all hitters with 230+ plate appearances. The piece argues his offensive decline forces the Phillies to rely on sub‑major‑league backups, urging a roster rethink before the championship window closes.
What are your MLB awards predictions?
MLB has released the finalists for its 2026 end‑of‑season awards, and Philadelphia’s trio—Cristopher Sánchez (NL Cy Young), Don Mattingly (NL Manager of the Year) and Jhoan Duran (NL Reliever of the Year)—keep the Phillies in the conversation despite a rough finish. The NL MVP race features Pete Crow‑Armstrong, Shohei Ohtani and Brice Turang, while the AL MVP spot pits Yordan Alvarez, Junior Caminero and Bobby Witt Jr. Other nominees include Cy Young contenders Jacob Misiorowski, Dylan Cease and Parker Messick, plus rookie and reliever categories. Fans are asked to weigh in on who will clinch the awards and whether any Philly player will claim a trophy.
Phillies News: Dave Dombrowski, Cristopher Sánchez, Albert Pujols
Dave Dombrowski confronts a roster overhaul as the Phillies enter a pivotal offseason, while Cy Young finalist Cristopher Sánchez looks to sharpen his sinker after a slight dip from 2025. Meanwhile, former Cardinals star Albert Pujols is set to interview for the Houston Astros managerial job, and the Oakland Athletics appoint Cam Castro as their new GM. With MLB free agency just kicking off and a looming December 1 lockout, the article previews the key moves shaping Philadelphia’s future and broader league headlines.
2026 Phillies Report Cards: Brad Keller
The Phillies’ $22 million, two‑year gamble on former Cubs reliever Brad Keller collapsed in 2026. After a promising 2025 breakout, Keller posted a 4.02 ERA over 32 games, with his strikeout rate dipping to 23.7% and WHIP inflating to 1.34. A forearm injury in June led to Tommy John surgery by mid‑July, ending his season and likely 2027. The move, once hailed as Dombrowski’s rare hit, left Philadelphia with a gaping bullpen void and an F‑grade performance. The article assesses why the signing failed and what it means for the Phillies’ offseason pursuit of a new setup arm for closer Jhoan Duran.
Who’ll be the next Phillie to win a major award?
Three Phillies—starting pitcher Cristopher Sánchez (Cy Young finalist), closer Jhoan Duran (Reliever of the Year finalist), and manager Don Mattingly (Manager of the Year finalist)—have earned spots on this year’s major award ballots. With the winners likely heading to other teams, the article ponders who the next Phillie to capture a top MLB honor will be, sparking debate among fans.
Phillies news: Alec Bohm, Bryce Harper, Jason Kanzler
Election season is over, which means no more political commercials on TV. Now, we just get to hear about the politics of baseball via negotiations. Hooray. On to the links. Phillies news: MLB news:
The Phillies have finalists for three awards
The Philadelphia Phillies snagged finals spots for three major awards. Manager Don Mattingly is a National League Manager of the Year finalist after steering the club from a 9‑19 start to a playoff berth and earning a contract extension. Reliever Jhoan Duran joins the Reliever of the Year finalists, boasting 33 saves, sub‑2.00 ERA and over 12 K/9 in the regular season. Pitcher Zack Sanchez is in the Cy Young race, highlighted by a lengthy scoreless‑inning streak, though the award looks to favor a rival ace. The article notes the slim odds of winning amid strong competition.
2026 Phillies report cards: Brooks Raley
The Good Phight grades Brooks Raley’s 2026 stint with the Philadelphia Phillies an F after a disastrous trade. Acquired from the Mets as a left‑handed setup man, Raley posted a 7.94 ERA over 11.1 innings in 16 games, going 0‑2 with a –0.3 WAR. After a shaky debut, he improved in August (3.12 ERA), but in September he blew a save and allowed ten hits, two homers, and four walks in just 3.2 innings, costing the Phillies six straight losses. The 38‑year‑old is now a free agent, and the article warns against future Mets reliever trades.
What is the best-case scenario for Aidan Miller in 2027?
After a back‑injury‑marred 2026, Phillies top prospect shortstop Aidan Miller returns pain‑free thanks to a routine inspired by Tom Brady’s TB12 method. In four minor‑league games he went 4‑14, and in the Arizona Fall League he’s hitting .359 with a 1.154 OPS, six extra‑base hits and six steals in 12 games. With the Phillies’ infield in flux—Alec Bohm and Edmundo Sosa heading into free agency and Trea Turner’s role uncertain—the best‑case scenario sees Miller cracking the MLB roster at third base or shortstop for the 2027 opening day, provided the lockout resolves.
Phillies news: Orion Kerkering, trades, Teruaki Sato
The Good Phight breaks down the Phillies’ offseason outlook, highlighting a Halloween party hosted by the team’s ball girls and a roundtable on trade targets. Analysts argue a trade for reliever Orion Kerkering may be inevitable as Philadelphia seeks to bolster its starting‑pitching depth. The article also notes MLB posting deadlines for Japan’s Kaima Taira, Hiromi Itoh, Teruaki Sato and Si‑Hwan Roh, and reviews top free‑agent options, with the Mets and Dodgers eyeing SP Tarik Skubal. A reminder caps the piece: the betting scandal involving Emmanuel Clase heads to trial.
Phillies claim two off of waivers from the Giants
The Phillies announced today that they claimed infielder Brett Harris and utility infielder Shay Whitcomb off waivers from the San Francisco Giants as they fine‑tune their roster for the offseason. Catcher Garrett Stubbs elected free agency, while right‑handers Brad Keller and Caleb Kilian, plus infielder/outfielder Felix Reyes, also part ways. Whitcomb, who saw limited action with the Giants and Astros last season (/.203/.233/.336 in 122 PA), adds defensive versatility but struggles offensively. Harris, a corner‑infielder who hit .288/.399/.449 in Triple‑A last year, offers similar depth. The moves reflect Philadelphia’s push for more roster flexibility ahead of upcoming roster cuts.
Compared to the Brewers, the Phillies don’t develop players
After the Brewers clinch the 2026 World Series, the Good Phight contrasts their development model with the Phillies’ drafting failures. The author argues the Phillies lag behind not because they need to copy Milwaukee but because they lack a strong player‑development pipeline. Using anonymized Baseball America scouting reports, the piece turns the draft into a quiz, letting readers choose between two infielders and two outfielders to see which players the Phillies actually selected. The exercise highlights missed opportunities and underscores how the Brewers and Rays succeeded by making smart, incremental moves rather than big‑ticket gambles.