Skip to main content

The Good Phight

https://www.thegoodphight.com/ | 220 entries published

Small victories, large defeats.

Latest Entries

Phillies add Zach McCambley, lose Griff McGarry in Rule 5 Draft, trade for Yoniel Curet

During the major league portion of MLB’s Rule 5 Draft, the Phillies added RHP reliever Zach McCambley from the Miami Marlins organization. However, they also lost the once promising (more on that) RHP Griff McGarry to the Washington Nationals. Zach McCambley is a former 3rd Round Pick out of the 2020 draft, is currently 26 […]

MLB

about 12 hours ago | 0 reads

Phillies potential trade target: MacKenzie Gore

I have been examining a few players who have been rumored to be available on the trade market. Today, I will look at Washington Nationals’ lefthanded starter MacKenzie Gore The background Originally drafted third overall by the San Diego Padres in the 2017 draft, Gore became a top ten prospect and reached the major leagues […]

about 14 hours ago | 0 reads

2025 Phillies player review: Jesús Luzardo

I remember exactly where I was when the news broke that the Phillies were trading for Jesús Luzardo. I was at home, and I interrupted my busy work of listening to Christmas music to do a writeup (Wonderful Christmastime is a great song, and I won’t hear any arguments to the contrary). “A new arm […]

about 16 hours ago | 0 reads

What Do You Think of the New Contracts?

Yesterday brought two pieces of welcome news, both contract-related. One was an extension: Rob Thomson’s contract now goes through the 2027 season. The other was a new contract for an old friend: Kyle Schwarber signed with the Phillies for 5 years and $150 million. The work of negotiating these contracts is hard. So many clauses […]

about 18 hours ago | 0 reads

Winter Meetings Day 2 Roundup

Here are today’s rumors from day two of the 2025 Winter Meetings. Kyle Schwarber is back Kyle Schwarber is reportedly finalizing a 5-year, $150 million with the Phillies. Schwarber is coming off the best year of his career, and will be signed through his age-37 season. Per Ken Rosenthal: The Orioles matched the offer made […]

1 day ago | 0 reads

Phillies sign Rob Thomson to contract extension

Moments after signing Kyle Schwarber to a reported five-year, $150 million deal, the Phillies announced the man who has managed Schwarber and the rest of this group since 2022, is getting another year tacked onto his deal. Rob Thomson, with a 346-251 record in four seasons as Phils’ skipper, has agreed to a contract taking […]

MLB

1 day ago | 0 reads

Breaking News: Kyle Schwarber is Back

He’s back! According to Jeff Passan, the Phillies are finalizing a five-year, $150 million deal with 2025 NL MVP runner up and home run king Kyle Schwarber. Schwarber’s 2025 was the best season of his 11-year career so far. His 56 homers led the NL and his 132 RBI led all of Major League Baseball. […]

1 day ago | 1 read

2025 Player Review: Seth Johnson

There are players on a team in a given year where there should be a role for them, but there isn’t. With pitchers, sometimes that role is a “we need you to be able to go back and forth between the majors and minors” type role. Those pitchers whose careers are in that mode right […]

1 day ago | 0 reads

Is there a real threat to the Phillies re-signing Kyle Schwarber?

This weekend, we saw the first report of a team making an actual offer to bring Kyle Schwarber into the fold. Granted, that offer came from the Pittsburgh Pirates, so it probably falls into the “we tried!” department. Still, we’ve seen reported interest from other teams like the Reds and Mets, with still others on […]

MLB

1 day ago | 0 reads

Phillies news: Don Mattingly, Kyle Schwarber, Winter Meetings

Welcome to day two of the Winter Meetings! True connoisseurs say that it’s the best day of the meetings. Onto the links. Phillies news The Phillies look to be getting close to bringing in Don Mattingly as bench coach. Dave Dombrowski talks a bit about where things stand for the Phillies as the Winter Meetings […]

MLB

2 days ago | 0 reads

Winter Meetings Day 1 rumor roundup

Let’s gather up all the rumors that are happening with the Phillies so far today. Is Kyle Schwarber close to signing? This is probably the least surprising rumor. Schwarber seems to be the thing clogging up the free agency market. One has to wonder if it’s that there is a lot of interest, or if […]

2 days ago | 0 reads

2025 Phillies player review: Daniel Robert

In search of relief depth early in the 2025 season, the Phillies traded for Rangers’ triple A righthander Daniel Robert. Although 30 years old and having just four games of major league experience under his belt, the Phillies thought he was worth the lottery ticket prospect (Enrique Segura) they gave up. Robert’s climb to the […]

3 days ago | 0 reads

Report: Kyle Schwarber received offer from the Pirates

In what might be termed “shocking” news, the Pirates – yes, the actual, real life Pittsburgh Pirates – have made an offer to Kyle Schwarber this offseason to come play for them. No word yet on what the offer was, but it being $100 million in gold doubloons should not be ruled out. This shouldn’t […]

3 days ago | 0 reads

Should Jeff Kent have been the only person elected to the Hall of Fame?

The Contemporary Committee spoke last night and opened the doors of Cooperstown to Jeff Kent and Jeff Kent alone. Of the 16 votes that were on the committee, Kent received 14, clearing the threshold needed to join the game’s elite. What’s been reported is that of all the other candidates, none were really that close […]

3 days ago | 0 reads

Phillies news: Japanese scouting, Kyle Schwarber, Jeff Kent

The Winter Meetings have begun and we’ve got a whole lot of nothing. You know what would make a good post? If we posted and talked about all the crazy rumors that are posited by those online. Some are actually alright in their nature, if woefully one-sided for the Phillies. Others look like people are […]

3 days ago | 0 reads

Phillies Winter Meetings preview

The Phillies enter this Winter Meetings at something of a crucial point in their championship window. We’ve all seen that the current core as constructed cannot finish the job as far as getting to the World Series and winning it, so there needs to be some changes to the roster. There has been much discussion […]

3 days ago | 0 reads

Did the Phillies miss the boat in trading for Harry Ford?

There are a lot of prospect hounds around and a lot of people like Harry Ford. This is the most updated scouting report, courtesy of Baseball Prospectus: If Ford was hoping he might play himself into a time-share at the catcher position by the end of 2025, he should’ve known better than to be drafted […]

MLB

4 days ago | 0 reads

Phillies news: Kyle Schwarber, J.T. Realmuto, Jose Ferrer

Maybe we just don’t value catching prospects in the same way that major league teams do. I would have thought someone like Harry Ford would have been worth much more than what the Mariners got for him, but Jose Ferrer is nothing to sneeze at either. We’ll never know what the Phillies could have dealt, […]

4 days ago | 0 reads

Phillies potential trade target: Sandy Alcantara

The hot stove has remained cool for the Phillies, so I’ll take another look at a player who has been rumored to be available on the trade market and analyze if he is someone the Phillies should pursue. Sandy Alcantara The background Sandy Alcantara was signed as an international free agent out of the Dominican […]

5 days ago | 0 reads

What do you want to see the Phillies do at the Winter Meetings?

Teams are starting to arrive in Florida for the Winter Meetings, getting ready for a few days of what we hope are transactions that light up the hot stove. That means that there will be trades, maybe a free agent signing or two and everyone’s favorite part of the Meetings, the Rule 5 draft. For […]

5 days ago | 0 reads

Phillies news: Kyle Schwarber, Nick Castellanos, Byron Buxton

The Winter Meetings, or how I learned to love baseball transactions again. Personally, I’m excited to see how many rumors are floated that are incredibly wrong or inaccurate. If we had to create a leaderboard for who had the most incorrect rumors around, which writer would lead the pack? My guess would be Ralph. On […]

5 days ago | 0 reads

The Notes Off-Season Check-In

The winter meetings take place early next week and hopefully that forces more action in free agency. Dylan Cease got a massive contract from Toronto but there hasn’t been much else outside of a few relievers. Who is going to sign Kyle Tucker? Mets Off-season so far This is a Phillies blog but it is […]

5 days ago | 0 reads

What are the odds as the Winter Meetings begin

The baseball Winter Meetings begin this weekend, which means the chances of the Phillies actually doing something within this timeframe are more heightened than ever. This is the place where business usually happens at a pretty steady pace and the Phillies are no stranger to that. The Winter Meetings is where Trea Turner agreed to […]

6 days ago | 0 reads

2025 Player Review: Mick Abel

To fully understand the whirlwind that was Mick Abel’s 2025 season, you have to start with how his 2024 season ended. The then 22-year-old Abel finished his first full season at Triple-A and “disaster” would hardly be the word for it. Abel started 24 games and finished with a 3-12 record to go with a […]

MLB

6 days ago | 0 reads