Skip to main content

The Good Phight

Small victories, large defeats.

Total reads

4,409

This week

76

Rank

#41 of 465

Published

1,973 posts

Active 32.9 posts/week Last post about 7 hours ago
Last 12 weeks

Most read posts

Featured on Sportsblogs

Run this blog? Add the badge to your site to show readers you're featured — it links back to this page.

Featured on Sportsblogs

Latest Entries

Should the Phillies extend Justin Crawford or Andrew Painter?

The Good Phight weighs the Phillies’ next move on two of their rising stars, shortstop Justin Crawford and left‑handed pitcher Andrew Painter. After the Mets locked A.J. Ewing into an eight‑year, $100 million deal, Philadelphia faces a similar decision: should they extend Painter, who posted a breakout 2026 season with a 2.86 ERA and 12 wins in the NL Wild Card Series, or keep Crawford, whose defensive versatility and 18‑home‑run breakout could make him a long‑term asset? The article breaks down each player’s 2026 impact and the potential value of a multi‑year contract.

Former Phillies’ Hall of Fame chances – Part one: The cameos

The Good Phight breaks down the seven former Phillies on the 2027 Hall of Fame ballot, starting with the “cameo” players whose Philly tenures were brief. Jake Arrieta’s three‑year stint after a Cy‑Young year with the Cubs earns him a vote at best, while Jay Bruce’s 2019 debut homers and later decline leave him off the Hall radar. Asdrúbal Cabrera’s mid‑season 2018 trade brought a 0.7 WAR dip as the club tanked, making his candidacy unlikely. The author promises to assess the four remaining, more impactful Phillies next.

Agree or disagree with the Phillies’ nontender decisions?

The Phillies have just reached the arbitration deadline for 2027, tendering contracts to expected players like Brandon Marsh, Orion Kerkering, and surprise catcher Rafael Marchan. However, notable nontenders include outfielder Bryan de la Cruz—who still had a minor‑league option—and pitcher Moises Chace, amid lingering Tommy John concerns. The club also added Jordan Leasure, who will miss the entire season due to injury, using a 40‑man roster spot. The article invites fans to weigh in on whether these moves make sense for Philadelphia’s roster strategy.

Phillies Roster Moves after Tender Deadline

The Phillies finalize their tender deadline moves, trading right‑hander Jordan Leasure to Chicago for Christian Coppola and signing Leasure for 2027 despite his upcoming Tommy John recovery. They avoid arbitration with left‑hand reliever Tanner Banks (1‑year, $1.3 M), Derek Hill and Rafael Marchán. Brandon Marsh, Bryson Stott, Jhoan Duran and Orion Kerkering are tendered, keeping arbitration options open. Bryan De La Cruz, Moises Chace, Brett Harris and Nolan Hoffmann are non‑tendered and become free agents. De La Cruz, a bench staple who hit .280 with a .762 OPS, and injured prospect Chace draw particular attention. No news yet on Tarik Skubal’s Mets deal.

Baseball Prospectus gives Phillies top ten list

Baseball Prospectus releases its top‑ten list of Philadelphia Phillies prospects for the 2027 season, naming players such as SS/3B Aidan Miller, RHP Gage Wood, OF Francisco Renteria, and RHP Brad Pacheco. The list, lifted from the pay‑wall, is accompanied by a stark quote from the prospectus: the Phillies suffer from a “weakest farm depth in the sport,” despite a solid top three. The article highlights the organization’s developmental challenges and the talent pool awaiting evaluation.

2026 Phillies report card: Chase Shugart

Chase Shugart, the Phillies’ 30‑year‑old reliever acquired from Pittsburgh in a trade for minor‑league pitcher Francisco Loreto, spent most of 2026 on the roster despite missing Opening Day. He logged 46 appearances (53.1 IP) with a 2‑1 record, 4.02 ERA, 59 strikeouts, 20 walks and a modest 0.8 WAR. Highlights include earning wins in both games of a doubleheader against the Giants in April and posting a 0.93 ERA over nine September outings. However, his fly‑ball style yielded too many baserunners and home runs. The author grades him a C, noting he’ll likely compete for a bullpen spot next season.

Are there any non-tender candidates you’re interested in?

The MLB arbitration deadline forces teams to decide by 5 p.m. which eligible players to tender contracts; those left untendered become free agents. The Phillies, known for snagging non‑tendered talent like Adolis García last year, are expected to hunt the market again as they juggle roster holes and budget caps. The article highlights how players such as Jonathan Loáisiga turned a non‑tender into value for the Diamondbacks and asks fans which potential free agents might be steals for Philadelphia in the coming season.

Phillies News: Chase Utley, Citizens Bank Park, Alec Bohm

As the MLB lockout looms and Thanksgiving approaches, the Phillies focus on roster needs and community outreach. A recent charity sleep‑over at Citizens Bank Park highlighted homelessness, while the team debates adding a left‑handed bat. The article examines Chase Utley's Cooperstown candidacy and critiques Alec Bohm's throwing accuracy among infielders. It also notes MLB headlines: Pete Rose’s presidential pardon, the White Sox’s trade of Davis Martin and Luis Castillo to Colorado, and previews for top free‑agent destinations.

Kyle Schwarber wins Silver Slugger; Bryce Harper robbed

Kyle Schwarber secures his second Silver Slugger as a Philadelphia Phillie, edging out Shohei Ohtani for the DH honor. He joins Bryce Harper (3) and J.T. Realmuto (2) as the only current Phillies with multiple awards, a feat not seen since Chase Utley in 2009. While Matt Olson claimed the First Base award, stats suggest Harper or Rafael Devers were stronger hitters. The piece also notes Jake Bauers’ utility‑player win and debates whether Ohtani’s superior OPS and wRC+ might have earned him the DH award instead of Schwarber.

2026 Phillies Report Card: Bryson Stott

Bryson Stott proves a defensive gem for the 2026 Phillies, posting a league‑best .998 fielding percentage at second base and a top‑10 defensive runs value, but a mid‑season shift to third—forced by the Luis Arraez trade—cost him a Gold Glove chance and added four errors in 43 games. Offensively, Stott hits .256/.334/.401 with 10 homers, 67 RBIs and a flawless 27‑for‑27 stolen‑base record. The author awards him a B grade, noting that staying at second could have pushed him to an A.

The Phillies are reportedly interested in Jonathan Loáisiga. Are you?

The Phillies are reportedly eyeing free‑agent reliever Jonathan Loáisiga after his breakout 2026 season with the Arizona Diamondbacks, where he posted a 2.42 ERA over 67 innings and a 56.4% ground‑ball rate. The 31‑year‑old right‑hander, who returned healthy from Tommy John surgery, offers high‑velocity fastballs (≈98 MPH) and strong control (5% walk rate). While the Phillies already have closer Jhoan Duran, Loáisiga could add depth to a right‑handed heavy bullpen, though it would leave them short on lefty arms. The article asks fans what contract they’d offer and how he’d fit.

Phillies News: Teruaki Sato, Brandon Marsh, Rob Manfred

As MLB’s pending lockout looms, the Phillies are busy eyeing offseason moves. ESPN’s Jeff Passan reports Philadelphia leads the chase for Japan’s hot‑hitting outfielder Teruaki Sato and could decide before Thanksgiving, while the team also weighs the future of versatile Brandon Marsh. Meanwhile, leaguewide headlines include Sonny Gray’s two‑year, $55 million return to the Twins, a six‑player trade sending Maikel Garcia to Seattle and Bryce Miller to Kansas City, and commissioner Rob Manfred’s firm stance that owners won’t budge on a new salary‑cap demand. The piece links to deeper analyses of these topics and a fun infield arm accuracy breakdown featuring a Phillie.

2026 Phillies report card: Cristopher Sanchez

The Good Phight’s 2026 Phillies report card crowns left‑hander Cristopher Sanchez with an A. After swapping Curtis Mead for Sanchez, the former Cy Young runner‑up logged a 2.91 ERA (2.80 FIP), 6.5 fWAR, and a record‑setting 50 2/3‑scoreless‑inning streak – the longest by a lefty in MLB history. Highlights include an All‑Star Game start on his home mound and a dominant playoff outing, while a summer stretch of 13 starts saw his ERA rise to 4.34. Despite those hiccups, Sanchez remains a top NL ace, and at a projected $7 M salary in 2027 the Phillies can build around his “Sanchez window” of contention.

Rounding up some minor league signings for the Phillies

As the MLB lockout looms on Dec. 2, the Phillies sprint to add minor‑league free agents. They sign former top‑100 prospect third‑baseman Bryan Ramos, who posted a .646 OPS in Triple‑A for the Orioles in 2026 after a steep drop from his White Sox ranking. Catcher depth arrives with Blake Hunt, a power‑capable second‑round pick, and Brian Navarreto, a defensive‑oriented back‑up who previously saw limited action with the Marlins. Right‑hander Geoff Hartlieb joins to provide strikeout upside in the minors. All moves aim to bolster the Lehigh Valley roster and hedge against injuries before the work stoppage.

What do you think of the Phillies’ protection deadline move?

The Good Phight examines the Phillies' recent Rule 5 deadline move, highlighting their decision to add infielder Bryan Rincon to the 40‑man roster to shield him from the upcoming draft. While the Rule 5 Draft often flies under the radar, the article questions the broader protection strategy and which prospects remain exposed, inviting fans to weigh in on the Phillies' roster choices amid potential lockout concerns.

Phillies news: Kyle Schwarber, Chase Utley, Randy Arozarena

The Phillies face a Friday arbitration deadline for 2027 contracts, prompting a look at unsigned talent like Cincinnati’s Matt McLain. Chase Utley tops the 2026 Hall of Fame ballot, while Kyle Schwarber is touted for another Silver Slugger. Philadelphia’s glaring need is a left‑handed reliever, yet the club explores right‑handed options. In broader MLB news, Dustin May signs a three‑year deal with the White Sox, Randy Arozarena draws early interest from the Yankees, and Baltimore continues to hunt starting pitching to revive its season.

Bryan Rincon added to 40-man roster, which is now at 39

The Philadelphia Phillies add prospect infielder Bryan Rincon to their 40-man roster, making him the only player protected from the Rule 5 Draft. The move, announced on the roster deadline of November 17, 2026, leaves the roster at 39 players and positions Rincon as a potential utility‑role replacement for Edmundo Sosa, while allowing him to develop in Lehigh Valley without risk of loss.

2026 Phillies Report Cards: Dylan Moore

The Phillies’ gamble on utility man Dylan Moore backfired. After signing him to a minor‑league deal in the offseason, Moore triggered an opt‑out and secured a $1.45 M major‑league contract, only to go hitless in 15 plate appearances (0‑0‑0, .000/.200/.000) and post a -0.2 WAR over 13 games. He saw limited action, pitching two mop‑up innings with a 5.40 ERA, and was outrighted to Triple‑A on May 8, where he hit .239/.692 in 87 games. The article grades his season D‑ and suggests 2026 may have been his final major‑league stint.

Previewing today’s protection deadline for the Phillies

The Phillies face a 6 p.m. deadline to add five prospects to their 40‑man roster before the Rule 5 draft, a critical move amid the looming MLB lockout. MLB Pipeline highlights shortstop Bryan Rincon (No. 4 prospect) as a near‑certain pick, utility infielder Aroon Escobar (No. 6) as a riskier addition after a down 2026, and 21‑year‑old Juan Villavicino (No. 19) likely left unprotected despite a strong start. RHP Wen‑Hui Pan (No. 20), returning from Tommy John, could be a surprise protectee, while LHP Mavis Graves (No. 26) may be left exposed despite the club’s left‑handed relief shortage. The article previews each player’s chances and the impact of lockout‑related training losses.

Who has your vote on the 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot?

The official 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot drops amid a quiet offseason, sparking debate over several Phillies-linked candidates. Notable names include Phillies greats Chase Utley, Jimmy Rollins, Bobby Abreu and Cole Hamels, plus former Phillie stand‑outs Jake Arrieta, Jay Bruce and Asdrubal Cabrera. Utley, who posted 59.1% of the vote in 2026—third behind inductees Carlos Beltrán and Andruw Jones—could finally break the 75% threshold, especially after a soft first‑year class aside from Buster Posey. Rollins and Abreu see modest gains, while Hamels garnered 23.8% as the top rookie‑eligible pitcher. Fans are asked to weigh in on which Phillie‑connected players might earn Cooperstown this year.

Phillies news: Dante Nori, AJ Minter, Tarik Skubal

The Good Phight’s November 17 post highlights several Phillies storylines: a deep dive into prospect outfielder Dante Nori, including his NBA‑coach father's influence; a preview of five Phillies prospects to protect in the upcoming Rule 5 Draft; and rumors that the club is eyeing former Mets reliever A.J. Minter. The article also covers broader MLB news, ranking each team’s odds of signing free‑agent ace Tarik Skubal, previewing the 2027 Hall of Fame ballot, and listing ten notable non‑tender moves. Readers get a quick roundup of key Phillies and league developments ahead of offseason action.

2026 Phillies report card: Trevor Richards

Righthanded journeyman Trevor Richards signed a minor‑league deal with the Phillies in December 2026, hoping to find consistency. After a strong minor‑league start, he debuted in late April, striking out two but walking one and surrendering a game‑tying single. He pitched 4.1 innings over two appearances, posting a 2.08 ERA, five strikeouts, three walks and leading the league with 12 wild pitches despite only 54 career innings. The Phillies sold him to Chicago to clear a roster spot, and at age 33 he is likely headed back to a minor‑league invite as a low‑leverage reliever.

Notes on Alex Vesia and an Outfield Idea

The piece warns that both Matt Strahm and Dodgers left‑hander Alex Vesia are showing classic aging‑curve red flags: declining fastball velocity, rising walk rates and slipping strikeout percentages despite respectable overall numbers. Vesia’s 31‑year‑old season may be his last strong one after 31 postseason appearances since 2021. The author then pivots to a potential outfield solution, arguing Luis Robert Jr. could be a solid one‑year right‑field signing for the Phillies. Though his OPS+ sits at 88 and he struggles with strike‑outs, his defensive ability and comparable value to the under‑performing Adolis García make him a viable, below‑average but dependable option. Other one‑year candidates like Tyrone Taylor and Randal Grichuk are also examined.