Skip to main content

The Good Phight

https://www.thegoodphight.com/ | 332 entries published

Small victories, large defeats.

Latest Entries

What should be the Phillies’ J.T. Realmuto backup plan?

Earlier this week, our own Ethan Witte wrote about possible destinations for J.T. Realmuto in free agency. It’s possible that Realmuto could receive a three-year deal despite turning 35 before Opening Day 2026. Realmuto is not the same player he once was, and he is clearly in the beginning of his decline. He posted his […]

2 months ago | 2 reads

Phillies news: José Alvarado, Kevin Long, Gage Wood

José Alvarado is officially returning to the Phillies, as the team did what Dave Dombrowski hinted at last month and picked up the lefty reliever’s $9M option for 2026. Alvarado had a nightmare 2025 that featured an 80-game suspension for performance enhancing drugs and an injury that ultimately cut his season short. Nevertheless, it makes […]

2 months ago | 3 reads

Phillies Exercise José Alvarado’s 2026 Option

The Phillies have reportedly exercised José Alvarado’s $9M option, officially returning him to the roster for 2026. Dave Dombrowski hinted that this move was likely back in his end of season press conference, so it doesn’t come as much of a surprise. Still, it is putting faith in Alvarado that he can return to form […]

2 months ago | 2 reads

Fixing the Phillies: Kyle Schwarber returns edition

With the World Series and the 2025 season officially in the rear view mirror, MLB’s Hot Stove season is officially upon us. For Phillies fans, it’s a chance to dream about how the front office can reinvent their outstanding roster in the hopes that, in 2026, the fifth time will be the charm. At this […]

2 months ago | 2 reads

2025 Player Review: Buddy Kennedy

Have you ever been in a win-win situation? They don’t come around too often, but when they do it’s a wonderful feeling. Maybe you got yourself into such a situation through hard work and grit. Maybe you got there through sheer dumb luck. Whatever the reason, no matter what choice you make or what fate […]

2 months ago | 0 reads

Who would you vote for on the Contemporary Era HoF Ballot?

It’s that time again: The Baseball Hall of Fame’s Contemporary Era committee will soon be meeting to consider candidates for Cooperstown. The committee votes get less attention than the main voting, but there’s plenty there to interest the baseball devotee: old favorites finally getting their due, interesting edge cases to bicker and banter over. This […]

MLB

2 months ago | 0 reads

Phillies news: Harrison Bader, free agents, Shane Bieber

It’s officially option decision season, and that means a lot of players are choosing if they’ll stay in their current spot or if they’ll foray into free agency. There have been some surprising decisions already and there will likely be more to come. On to the links. Phillies news: MLB news:

2 months ago | 2 reads

Harrison Bader declines mutual option, becomes free agent

In what was bound to happen, Harrison Bader parlayed his best season in a while into his opting out his end of a mutual option and will head into free agency once again. This was going to happen, so it should be no surprise. He had a very good season and will be in demand. […]

2 months ago | 3 reads

J.T. Realmuto might get a three-year deal, but from who?

This week, there was an answer to the question about J.T. Realmuto returning to the Phillies and what kind of contract he would get. Matt Gelb, ever the insider, predicted a three-year deal is not entirely off the table. Yadier Molina signed a three-year extension in 2018 that covered his age-35 to -37 seasons. That […]

2 months ago | 3 reads

2025 player review: Brett de Geus

Brett de Geus certainly gets around. Since being drafted in 2017, Brett de Geus has spent time with nine different organizations, including two stints with the Miami Marlins. He started the year with the Blue Jays (who had claimed him off waivers in September), but they sold him to the Pirates, with whom he opened […]

2 months ago | 1 read

Give some award predictions!

Yesterday, all of the finalists for the major awards in baseball were announced, almost like a fleeting moment in the wind thanks to MLB not advertising anything about it for any point. Such is life. Now that we know all of the finalists for each of the categories, let’s make today’s question a simple question […]

MLB

2 months ago | 0 reads

Kyle Schwarber is an MVP finalist

In what really shouldn’t be a shocking surprise, Kyle Schwarber is a finalist for the National League MVP award. One of the better contract years in recent memory, Schwarber passed the 50 home run benchmark with ease while racking up 130+ RBI. He was a run scoring threat each time he stepped to the plate. […]

MLB

2 months ago | 0 reads

2025 Phillies Player Review: Alec Bohm

In 2024, Alec Bohm put together the best season of his career, made the All-Star Game, and then struggled in the second half. He was benched in game two of the National League Division Series against the New York Mets and faced dozens of different trade rumors throughout the winter. Given Dave Dombrowski’s history of […]

2 months ago | 3 reads

Where does this World Series rank?

Instant takes about how great a World Series is is the new norm. We live in an age where everything has to be ranked, from sports teams to Halloween candy. Nothing can simply exist any longer. It needs to be placed in some kind of strange pantheon among all other subjects that are tangentially related. […]

MLB

2 months ago | 0 reads

Phillies news: World Series, J.T. Realmuto, Yoshinobu Yamamoto

Now that the fun begins, let’s put to bed one of the fallacies that is following the thriller that was Game 7: MLB doesn’t need a salary cap. That’s just crazy. MLB needs more owners to act like they want to do something other than create a tremendous profit for themselves. Not really a common […]

2 months ago | 2 reads

What will be the biggest move in MLB this offseason?

So now that the confetti is cleared, let’s focus on what’s ahead. Often times, for some fans at least, the offseason is where the action is. Thanks to fantasy sports, we live in a perpetual time of trade ideas and free agent desires. Some fans like that action more than the action that takes place […]

MLB

2 months ago | 0 reads

Phillies news: Nick Castellanos, Edmundo Sosa, Lucas Giolito

The World Series is now over, we have a champion….and now we are done. The offseason will officially begin in five days and a flurry of moves will definitely not happen. We all know that the offseason moves at a glacial pace and with the uncertainty that surrounds game thanks to the CBA negotiations that […]

2 months ago | 2 reads

World Series Game 7 open thread

It’s the best night of the baseball calendar. Game 7 of the World Series, where anything can happen. Let’s talk about it.

MLB

2 months ago | 0 reads

The Phillies should spend how much?!?!

The other day, we asked you a question about the team’s payroll. It’s a target that is constantly shifting for unknown reasons, but Dave Dombrowski has gone on record as saying he gave something to John Middleton and it was approved. What that number was, we won’t know, but here is what you think that […]

2 months ago | 2 reads

Who wins Game 7?

The Blue Jays had multiple chances to take their first World Series since 1993 last night, but could not get the job done. Addison Barger will be the face of it thanks to his game ending baserunning blunder, but they had a few chances to put up runs and didn’t. Now, they get Shohei Ohtani […]

2 months ago | 2 reads

A very Phillies Halloween

The Phillies and Halloween: A tradition like no other? Actually, there’s not really much history for the Phillies on Halloween. It used to be that the baseball season was well wrapped up by the time the 31st came around. But these days, with the addition of extra playoff rounds, the World Series now regularly stretches […]

2 months ago | 2 reads

2025 Player Review: Brandon Marsh

A weirdo with the perfect personality for the city of Philadelphia, Brandon Marsh is beloved by all demographics of Phillies fans. Whether he’s barking in people’s faces, sharing his infectious laugh, or hyping up his teammates, there’s no shortage of appreciation for his antics. More than anything, Brandon Marsh is a quality teammate — something […]

2 months ago | 1 read